Every adaptation on this list was made by people who gave up something to fit a novel on a screen. Tolstoy loses his essays on history, Hugo loses his sewers, Eliot loses her narrator. The discs below are the ones worth owning, and each is paired with the edition of the book to read after the credits.
Quick pick: for a gift, buy the restored BBC Pride and Prejudice on Blu-ray with the Penguin Clothbound novel. For a long winter weekend, buy the two-disc BBC Middlemarch or the Lionsgate War and Peace Blu-ray, and read the Penguin Briggs translation of Tolstoy afterwards.
Which classic adaptation should you own?
The adaptations, one by one
Pride and Prejudice, BBC 1995: the one to own
Simon Langton’s miniseries, with Colin Firth and Jennifer Ehle, is the adaptation other adaptations are measured against. Because it has hours rather than minutes, it can keep the drawing-room talk where Austen’s comedy lives. Amazon lists a BBC Studios release restored from the original film negatives, and a Blu-ray and DVD combination, which makes it the version to give. The listings for this title disagree about disc counts and runtime, so read the product page before ordering.
Read the novel after it in the Penguin Clothbound hardcover, or choose the Penguin Classics paperback if you only want a reading copy. Our Pride and Prejudice edition guide compares every option. See the Penguin Clothbound hardcover.
Pride and Prejudice, 2005: the two-hour version
Joe Wright’s film, with Keira Knightley and Matthew Macfadyen, gets through the whole story in about two hours, so it gives up most of the minor characters and much of the dialogue. It is the version for a viewer who wants mud, candlelight and a fast pace. Amazon lists a 4K Ultra HD, Blu-ray and digital combination.
See the 2005 4K and Blu-ray set
War and Peace, 2016: Tolstoy in six hours
The BBC series stars Paul Dano as Pierre, Lily James as Natasha and James Norton as Andrei. The US Blu-ray from Lionsgate runs 5 hours 54 minutes according to its listing, which is a tiny fraction of the book. Expect Natasha, Pierre and Andrei, balls, the battle of Borodino and the burning of Moscow. Do not expect Tolstoy’s long arguments about how history works. See the War and Peace Blu-ray. A DVD edition also exists. UK imports are region-coded, so choose the US listing unless you own a multi-region player.
For the book, choose Anthony Briggs in Penguin Classics if you want smooth modern English, or the Penguin Clothbound edition as a gift. Pevear and Volokhonsky leave Tolstoy’s French in, which some readers prefer. Our War and Peace translation guide has the details. See the Briggs paperback. See the Briggs Clothbound hardcover.
Anna Karenina, 2012: the film that puts the novel on a stage
Tom Stoppard wrote the screenplay and Joe Wright set much of it inside a theater, with Keira Knightley as Anna and Jude Law as Karenin. It divides viewers, which is a good reason to watch it with someone. The Blu-ray listing describes two discs, a director’s commentary and an “Adapting Tolstoy” extra.
The book is the better answer to what the film leaves out: Levin and the farm. Pevear and Volokhonsky are the standard modern translation, and Rosamund Bartlett’s Oxford edition has the best notes. See the Pevear and Volokhonsky paperback. See the Bartlett paperback. The Anna Karenina guide explains the choice.
Les Misérables, 2018: Hugo without the singing
This six-hour Masterpiece series, with Dominic West as Jean Valjean and David Oyelowo as Javert, is the straight drama, not the musical. The DVD listing shows two discs and PBS as the distributor.
The novel runs well past a thousand pages, so avoid any copy that is abridged. Julie Rose’s Modern Library paperback is brisk and complete, and Christine Donougher’s Penguin Deluxe adds notes. See the Julie Rose paperback. See the Donougher Penguin Deluxe. Our Les Misérables guide covers the rest.
Middlemarch, BBC 1994: the novel’s long evenings on disc
Juliet Aubrey plays Dorothea Brooke and Douglas Hodge plays Lydgate. The BBC DVD lists two discs and a runtime of 5 hours 57 minutes. Middlemarch is a novel of Dorothea’s marriage, Lydgate’s ambition and a whole town, which is why a long serial suits it better than a film does.
For the book, the Penguin Classics paperback has Rosemary Ashton’s introduction and notes and follows the text of the 1874 second edition. It is 880 pages. The Penguin Clothbound edition is the gift copy. See the Penguin Classics paperback. See the Penguin Clothbound hardcover.
Listen to it
If you would rather hear the book first, these recordings are unabridged.
- Pride and Prejudice, read by Rosamund Pike. Unabridged, 11 hours 35 minutes, from Audible Studios. Listen on Audible.
- War and Peace, read by Thandiwe Newton. Unabridged, 60 hours 14 minutes, the Maude translation, from Audible Studios. Listen on Audible.
- Anna Karenina, read by Miranda Pleasence. Unabridged, 36 hours 59 minutes, the Pevear and Volokhonsky translation, from Penguin Audio. Listen on Audible.
- Les Misérables, Penguin Classics, read by Adeel Akhtar and a cast. The Donougher translation, 65 hours 41 minutes, from Penguin Audio. Listen on Audible.
New Audible members can usually try a membership free. See Audible membership options.
Common questions
What is the best adaptation of Pride and Prejudice?
The 1995 BBC miniseries with Colin Firth and Jennifer Ehle is the one most viewers choose, because it has room for the whole story. The 2005 film is the shorter alternative.
Should I read the book before or after the adaptation?
For the long Russian novels, many viewers watch first and read second, since the series gives them the characters. For Austen and Eliot, either order works. Pick whichever makes you more likely to finish.
Will a UK disc play in the US?
Often not. Several UK listings are region-coded and say so. The links above point to US listings where we found one. Read the region note on any product page.
Are Blu-ray and DVD box sets good gifts?
They are, especially when paired with a hardcover of the novel. The Penguin Clothbound editions of Austen, Eliot and Tolstoy match the discs above.



